Overview
This role serves as the senior legal leader responsible for litigation strategy across the Accident & Health (A&H) Specialty Business Unit (SBU) product portfolio. Primary responsibility covers Occupational Accident and Alternative Risk programs, with additional support for other SBU products as appropriate.
Responsibilities include leading significant litigation, claims disputes, coverage matters, class actions, pro se matters, and emerging litigation risks. The role also functions as a strategic business partner to Claims, Underwriting, SBU Executive Leadership, Legal, Finance, Operations, Regulatory and Compliance.
Responsibilities
Strategic Litigation Leadership
- Establish and lead litigation strategy for Occupational Accident and Alternative Risk programs, including significant, high-exposure, complex, precedent-setting, coverage, class action, pro se, and emerging litigation matters.
- Exercise senior-level judgment on litigation posture, trial and settlement strategy, escalation, outside counsel engagement, and significant financial exposure.
- Establish litigation governance, escalation protocols, guidelines, portfolio review processes, and consistent reporting standards.
- Lead negotiation, mediation, and settlement strategy to achieve commercially reasonable outcomes aligned with the A&H Division’s risk tolerance and broader business objectives.
- Provide timely assessments of significant litigation exposures, trends, and emerging risks to A&H Legal and SBU Executive Leadership.
- Partner with Claims, Finance, and TPAs regarding reserving considerations, settlement strategy, and material changes in portfolio risk.
Strategic Business Partnership & Program Strengthening
- Serve as a strategic partner to A&H Legal and SBU Executive Leadership by analyzing litigation, claims, settlement, and dispute trends and translating litigation experience into stronger, sustainable programs and corrective strategies.
- Recommend enhancements to policy language, program structures, underwriting guidelines, claims protocols, contracts, TPA practices, distribution arrangements, documentation, and operational processes to reduce litigation risk and improve program performance.
- Ensure lessons learned from litigation—including patterns arising from AI-assisted or pro se matters—are incorporated into program reviews, underwriting, claims handling, product development, partner oversight, and preventive measures, while balancing profitability, partner relationships, reputational and precedent risk, and long-term portfolio objectives.
- Identify emerging legal and litigation developments that may affect program structure, economics, viability, or strategic direction.
Claim Counsel Leadership & Legal-Claims Integration
- Partner with A&H Claims leadership to establish consistent litigation strategies, legal standards, escalation criteria, reporting expectations, playbooks, and best practices (including for AI-assisted and pro se litigation).
- Conduct regular SBU portfolio and significant-matter reviews and provide substantive legal guidance on complex, high-exposure, novel, or strategically significant matters.
- Maintain an integrated Legal-Claims litigation-management model defining matter ownership, decision rights, escalation protocols, and accountability.
- Identify opportunities to strengthen capabilities through training, analytics, outside counsel management, technology, and standardized processes.
AI-Enabled & Emerging Litigation Risk
- Develop and lead the A&H Division’s strategy for emerging litigation risks associated with generative AI and AI-assisted pro se litigation, including scalable approaches for triage, escalation, defense, resolution, and appropriate challenge of complaints, pleadings, discovery, motions, correspondence, and other litigation activity.
- Monitor AI-enabled litigation trends and patterns—including frequency, severity, defense costs, recurring allegations, theories of liability, jurisdictions, claimant strategies, and claims-handling issues—to identify matters presenting meaningful legal, financial, regulatory, reputational, precedent, or broader portfolio risk.
- Partner with A&H Claim, Claim Counsel, TPAs, outside counsel, and business stakeholders to establish efficient and consistent defense strategies for potentially high-volume AI-assisted litigation while maintaining appropriate individualized legal analysis.
- Evaluate and implement legal technology and AI-enabled tools for litigation intake, analysis, tracking, and trend identification, consistent with confidentiality, privilege, data security, accuracy, human oversight, and responsible AI use.
- Provide education and guidance to key stakeholders related to these tools and approaches.
Portfolio Risk, Analytics & Continuous Improvement
- Develop and maintain a portfolio-level view of litigation exposure and performance, including frequency and severity, disposition and settlement trends, legal spend, trial outcomes, jurisdictional trends, recurring allegations, and TPA and outside counsel performance.
- Define and track litigation lifecycle, resolution, cost, and performance metrics; translate data and trends into actionable recommendations regarding program strategy, risk mitigation, claims practices, underwriting, product design, partner management, and resource allocation.
- Leverage technology, processes, and tools to enhance litigation oversight, analytics, consistency, and scalability.
- Identify opportunities for early resolution, cost containment, process improvement, and prevention of recurring disputes.
Outside Counsel & External Litigation Leadership
- Develop and maintain a national network of outside litigation counsel with appropriate expertise in Occupational Accident and Alternative Risk programs.
- Direct counsel on case strategy, budgeting, discovery, motion practice, mediation, trial preparation, and resolution strategy.
- Establish and manage outside counsel expectations for performance, staffing, budgeting, reporting, efficiency, and strategic alignment, including selection, evaluation, and retention decisions.
- Serve as a senior legal representative in significant mediations, settlement negotiations, and other matters involving material financial, legal, reputational, or business risk.
Risk Mitigation, Contracts & Cross-Functional Partnership
- Advise on risk mitigation strategies involving policy language, claims handling practices, program structures, and partner arrangements.
- Partner with transactional counsel and business stakeholders to incorporate litigation lessons into MGA/MGU, TPA, program, distribution, affinity, and other agreements, including provisions related to claims authority, litigation management, cooperation, indemnification, data, audit, and risk allocation.
- Partner with Regulatory & Compliance regarding litigation-related regulatory inquiries, trends, and reporting obligations.
- Build working relationships across A&H Legal and SBU Executive Leadership, Claims, Underwriting, Finance, Operations, Regulatory, Compliance, TPAs, MGAs/MGUs, and other strategic partners.
Requirements
- J.D. degree, admitted to a State Bar, and eligible for or willing to obtain a NJ Limited-License In-House Counsel license within one year of employment commencement.
- 8+ years of relevant litigation experience, including significant experience managing complex litigation and providing strategic legal advice in an in-house, law firm, or comparable environment.
- Strong preference for in-house litigation management experience within Occupational Accident or Alternative Risk environments; other Accident & Health SBU product experience (e.g., Pet, Travel) a plus.
- Demonstrated experience leading attorneys, claims professionals, outside counsel, or cross-functional teams; matrixed or dotted-line leadership experience strongly preferred.
- Experience advising senior business leaders on litigation risk, resolution strategy, and program-level risk mitigation.
- Strong PC skills including Excel, Word, Outlook, and PowerPoint.
Preferred Qualifications
- Strong preference for in-house litigation management experience within Occupational Accident or Alternative Risk environments.
- Matrixed or dotted-line leadership experience.
Compensation & Benefits
- Competitive compensation package
- Generous 401K employer match
- Employee Stock Purchase plan with employer matching
- Generous Paid Time Off
- Excellent benefits beyond health, dental & vision, with programs focused on whole-family wellness, including physical, mental, and financial wellbeing
- Tuition reimbursement, industry-related certifications, and professional training
- Potential discretionary equity (stock) and/or performance-based variable pay programs
Pay range (annualized base pay): $123,200.00 to $231,800.00. Discretionary equity and/or performance-based variable pay may be available.
Location
Salary ranges are available for positions at this location. (Location details were not specified in the provided text.)