Overview
This role supervises the team responsible for reviewing complex, escalated, and exception-based personal injury opportunities that require additional investigation and judgment before a final case decision is made. You will serve as the first level of expert case review, accountable for the quality, consistency, and speed of qualification decisions.
The Supervisor is a hands-on leader who develops specialist judgment, analyzes case and funnel trends, and partners across Intake, Legal, QA, Learning & Development, and Analytics to improve how viable cases are identified, evaluated, and advanced.
Responsibilities
- Lead, coach, and develop Case Qualification Specialists through regular one-on-ones, case reviews, performance discussions, and ongoing feedback.
- Act as the first escalation point for complex or unclear case opportunities; personally review cases involving ambiguous liability, significant injuries, commercial involvement, government entities, conflicting facts, or other exceptions.
- Ensure specialists gather and validate the information needed to make a well-supported recommendation to sign, refer, or decline, and determine when attorney guidance is required.
- Monitor case volume, turnaround time, aging, follow-up activity, decision quality, documentation, productivity, and client experience; take action when performance falls outside expectations.
- Analyze qualification outcomes, attorney overrides, decline and referral trends, missed opportunities, and case-level data to identify root causes and improvement opportunities.
- Review Intake calls, questionnaires, and documentation to identify upstream gaps and recommend improvements to questions, workflows, criteria, scripts, job aids, training, and escalation rules.
- Partner with Intake Operations, Legal, QA, Learning & Development, Analytics, and other stakeholders to improve qualification accuracy, reduce unnecessary escalations, and strengthen case identification.
- Ensure prospective clients with escalated cases receive timely, professional, and empathetic communication, and that cases do not stall due to unclear ownership or insufficient follow-up.
- Promote a culture of curiosity, accountability, critical thinking, and sound judgment so specialists evaluate the facts of each opportunity rather than relying solely on scripts or checklists.
Requirements
- Strong experience in personal injury intake, claims, case evaluation, paralegal work, legal operations, or a related field.
- Demonstrated understanding of personal injury liability, injury severity, case-value indicators, and common case qualification considerations.
- Strong investigative and critical-thinking skills with the ability to work through incomplete, conflicting, or ambiguous information.
- Ability to make sound, defensible recommendations while recognizing when additional investigation or attorney guidance is appropriate.
- Analytical mindset with the ability to use case and performance data to identify trends, root causes, and improvement opportunities.
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to summarize complex case facts and recommendations clearly and concisely.
- Strong organizational skills and ability to manage multiple high-priority cases, competing deadlines, and sensitive client situations.
- Experience with CRM, case-management, or contact-center systems; Salesforce and Filevine experience preferred.
Preferred Qualifications
- Previous supervisory, team-lead, coaching, or leadership experience strongly preferred.
Compensation & Benefits
Location
Reporting / Team
- Reports to: Director of Intake Operations
- Direct reports: Case Qualification Specialists